Justin Pickard reviewed The Rose Field by Philip Pullman
Late Capitalism in Lyra's World
4 stars
Disconcertingly long, causing me to sail straight past the library due date. I probably should have re-read the previous books in the sequence first, instead of leaping straight in. A bit shaggy, structurally, but some effective characterisation and some genuinely strong scenes and plot lines. The universal solvent is – what exactly? Late capitalism (arriving ahead of schedule, through fungible currency and potash), alienation from the fruits of one's labour, a broader disenchantment of the world? Or all three at once, refracted through a fictionalised Belt and Road initative?
Disconcertingly long, causing me to sail straight past the library due date. I probably should have re-read the previous books in the sequence first, instead of leaping straight in. A bit shaggy, structurally, but some effective characterisation and some genuinely strong scenes and plot lines. The universal solvent is – what exactly? Late capitalism (arriving ahead of schedule, through fungible currency and potash), alienation from the fruits of one's labour, a broader disenchantment of the world? Or all three at once, refracted through a fictionalised Belt and Road initative?